A dismissal may be challenged on several grounds: discrimination, manifest unreasonableness, abuse of the right to dismiss, or breach of the protection afforded to employee representatives. Can the employee then claim several compensation payments? In three judgments of 12 October 2026, the Court of Cassation provides the answer.
Where a dismissal breaches several rules, it may be tempting to add together the compensation payments provided for under each of them. However, such combination is not automatic.
To determine whether combination is possible, the legal basis and purpose of each compensation payment must be examined. The court therefore considers whether they compensate genuinely distinct losses or, under different labels, the consequences of the same conduct by the employer.
Manifestly unreasonable dismissal and discrimination
The first case concerned an employee who was frequently absent and was dismissed because of the disruption caused by those absences to the organisation of the undertaking.
The employee claimed compensation for manifestly unreasonable dismissal and compensation for discrimination on the grounds of health status. The Court reiterates that, save in exceptional circumstances, compensation for manifestly unreasonable dismissal may not be combined with another compensation payment due in connection with the termination of the employment contract.
Where the same dismissal is found to be both discriminatory and manifestly unreasonable, compensation for discrimination falls within that category. The two compensation payments therefore cannot be added together.
Manifestly unreasonable dismissal and abuse of the right to dismiss
In the second case, an employee had been sanctioned by suspension from work because of his conduct. A few months later, he was dismissed for the same conduct, without any new misconduct having been established in the meantime.
Compensation for manifestly unreasonable dismissal provides lump-sum compensation for the financial and non-financial loss arising from the manifestly unreasonable nature of the dismissal. Compensation for abuse of the right to dismiss, for its part, is intended to compensate the loss caused by the employer’s abuse.
That distinction is not sufficient to permit combination. If the abuse of right and the manifestly unreasonable nature of the dismissal are based on the same facts, without any additional fault on the employer’s part, the two compensation payments cover the same loss and cannot be combined.
Discrimination and protection of candidates in social elections
The third case concerned an employee representative who was dismissed without compliance with the protection procedure laid down by the Law of 19 March 1991. The employer had paid the protection compensation, but the employee also claimed compensation for discrimination based on trade union beliefs.
According to the Court, the special protection afforded to candidates in social elections constitutes a specific form of protection against discrimination linked to trade union beliefs. Where the alleged discrimination lies solely in the dismissal itself, the protection compensation and the discrimination compensation therefore cover, in principle, the same financial and non-financial loss. Here again, they cannot be combined.
These judgments confirm that an employee cannot automatically obtain several compensation payments in connection with the same dismissal.
Before allowing or ruling out a combination, three questions should therefore be asked: what is the legal basis of each compensation payment, is there a prohibition on combining them, what purpose does each payment pursue, and what specific loss does it compensate? In the absence of an express provision prohibiting combination, a combination may, where appropriate, be considered only if the losses are genuinely distinct.
By Marjolaine Dessard – Senior Associate Claeys & Engels